McDonald's Menu Prices at 3400 Sheridan Drive ★3.7 (2023)

3400 Sheridan Drive, Amherst, NY 14226

Paul Schwartz 6 months ago

★★☆☆☆

Placed my take out order yesterday 9/10/25 arount 4:30 pm. In the Happy Meal we ordered we found a used crumbled up napkin. This Filet o Fish [pictured] was sadly, the better of the two that I was served . We've been customers at this this location for over 40 years but have found the quality of your food has really degraded over the last year. Such a shame

Lindsey Cruz a month ago

★★★★★

Let me start by saying I’m 8 months pregnant so I’ve had my fair share of McDonald’s lately�� the ladies working today at this location GOT ME RIGHT. Food was hot & packaged with care. Service was friendly and FAST. Way to go ladies 👏👏 10/10

Richard Chapman 2 years ago

★★★★☆

The new renovations were greatly disappointing. They removed the drink station and built a wall to hide the staff. They don't want you to see your food being made because they are ashamed of their staffs image. However, this is still the highest quality mcdonald's in the area when it comes to food and service. This location cares way more than other locations.

Taysha Virgil a month ago

★★☆☆☆

Just when I thought it was getting better. Not much has changed in the years going here. They had a sign that said if the person taking the order didn't acknowledge you using the app and greeted you by name you get a cookie. Well I asked and no cookies were even made, no substitute offered. How lazy to have something to make your employees do, but then they can't even fulfill something you decided to offer. Food quality has been declining. I really hope this location can improve

Spencer Cappon 3 months ago

★☆☆☆☆

Says open 24 hours. I work late shifts and odd hours. Only restaurant apparently open. They refuse to answer the window at weird hours when people are inside. Waste my time more. I will keep coming back and complaining. Sat at window Monday 12/8, I even pulled up to the drive-through window and the clearly saw me. Very unprofessional they cannot even answer the window to tell me to wait, but ignore the customer. Also two people inside working by the way. Mcdonalds is proving to be un reliable at odd hours unlike they used to be known for. Sad times we live in with bad quality service.

ZIP 14226 Amherst New York ☀️ 48°F · Sunny · Oct 17

McDonald's Menu with Prices at This Location

How It Compares

Nearby McDonald's Locations Within 5 Miles

Other Locations in Amherst

All Amherst prices →

After You Eat — What's Nearby?

🗺️

👨‍👩‍👧 families

The Buffalo Zoo

The seventh oldest zoo in the U.S., home to over 1,200 animals and various exhibits, making it a great destination for families and animal enthusiasts.

🌟 all

North Park Theatre

A historic single-screen movie theatre showcasing a mix of mainstream, independent, and foreign films in a beautifully restored setting.

🌟 all

Chestnut Ridge Park

A 1,213-acre park featuring hiking trails, disc golf, and the famous Eternal Flame Falls, suitable for nature lovers and adventure seekers.

👨‍👩‍👧 families

Buffalo Harbor State Park

A 190-acre park and marina on Lake Erie, offering waterfront activities and scenic views, perfect for a leisurely stroll or picnic.

🌟 all

Amherst State Park

An 80-acre park offering nature trails and biking paths along Ellicott Creek, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts seeking a peaceful retreat.

🌟 couples|families

Taste of India

An authentic Indian restaurant known for its flavorful dishes and warm ambiance, ideal for a date night or family dinner.

McDonald's 3400 Sheridan Drive — Frequently Asked Questions

McDonald's menu prices at 3400 Sheridan Drive, Amherst NY in 2026

The McDonald's menu at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY currently lists Big Mac at $6.79, Medium Fries at $3.99, and 20-piece Chicken McNuggets at $8.59. This store is also showing limited-time items including Derpy McFlurry at $6.59, Ramyeon McShaker Fries at $4.49, Saja Boys Breakfast Meal at $7.69. Every menu item on this page is pulled from the McDonald's app for this specific location and last verified October 2026.

How much is a Big Mac at McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive?

A Big Mac at the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY is $6.79 as of October 2026. The Amherst city average is $7.08 and the US national average is $5.91. This location is $0.88 above the national average.

McDonald's fries price at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst

Medium French Fries at the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY are $3.99 as of October 2026. See how this compares to other Amherst stores on our city page.

McNuggets price on the McDonald's menu at 3400 Sheridan Drive

20-piece Chicken McNuggets at the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY cost $8.59 as of October 2026. Compare McNuggets prices at other Amherst stores on our city page.

Is the limited-time Derpy McFlurry available at McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive?

Yes. The limited-time Derpy McFlurry is currently listed at the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY for $6.59 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.

Is the limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries available at McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive?

Yes. The limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries is currently listed at the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY for $4.49 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.

Is the limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal available at McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive?

Yes. The limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal is currently listed at the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY for $7.69 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.

Is the McDonald's menu at 3400 Sheridan Drive more expensive than the Amherst average?

The Big Mac at this McDonald's is $6.79. The Amherst, NY average Big Mac is $7.08, and the US national average is $5.91. This store is below the Amherst average.

Why are McDonald's menu prices at 3400 Sheridan Drive different from other locations?

McDonald's menu prices at 3400 Sheridan Drive are set by the local franchise owner — not McDonald's corporate. Amherst averages $7.08 for a Big Mac, which is $1.17 above the US average of $5.91. There are 2 McDonald's in Amherst — visit our city page to compare them all.

How many items are on the McDonald's menu at 3400 Sheridan Drive?

This McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY has 21 menu items listed above with current app prices. Browse the full menu on this page or compare with other locations in Amherst.

When were McDonald's menu prices at 3400 Sheridan Drive last updated?

Prices for the McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY were last verified October 2026. We source data from the McDonald's mobile app. Franchise owners can adjust prices at any time — check back for the latest.

What is there to do near McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst?

Explore the diverse attractions nearby, from enjoying wildlife at the Buffalo Zoo to watching a film at the historic North Park Theatre. Outdoor lovers will appreciate the serenity of Amherst State Park and Chestnut Ridge Park, while food enthusiasts can savor authentic Indian cuisine. Top nearby spots: The Buffalo Zoo — The seventh oldest zoo in the U.S., home to over 1,200 animals and various exhibits, making it a great destination for families and animal enthusiasts.; North Park Theatre — A historic single-screen movie theatre showcasing a mix of mainstream, independent, and foreign films in a beautifully restored setting.; Chestnut Ridge Park — A 1,213-acre park featuring hiking trails, disc golf, and the famous Eternal Flame Falls, suitable for nature lovers and adventure seekers.; Buffalo Harbor State Park — A 190-acre park and marina on Lake Erie, offering waterfront activities and scenic views, perfect for a leisurely stroll or picnic.; Amherst State Park — An 80-acre park offering nature trails and biking paths along Ellicott Creek, ideal for outdoor enthusiasts seeking a peaceful retreat..

What McDonald's locations are near 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst?

There are 10 McDonald's locations within 5 miles of 3400 Sheridan Drive in Amherst, NY: 1. McDonald's at 1385 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14226 (1.1 mi away) — rated 3.7 out of 5; 2. McDonald's at 3540 Main St, Amherst, NY 14226 (1.6 mi away) — rated 3.3 out of 5; 3. McDonald's at 1970 Kensington Ave, Buffalo, NY 14215 (2.4 mi away) — rated 2.8 out of 5.

MenuPriceTracker vs. Delivery Apps & Other Price Sites

How do these prices compare to what Uber Eats, DoorDash, or Grubhub show?

Uber Eats, DoorDash, Grubhub, and Seamless inflate McDonald's menu prices by 15–30% on top of the in-store price before adding delivery fees, service fees, and tip. The price you see on a delivery app is not what McDonald's charges at the counter. MenuPriceTracker shows the real menu price from the McDonald's app — what you'd actually pay walking into the restaurant or ordering at the kiosk.

Why not just check TripAdvisor for McDonald's prices?

TripAdvisor doesn't track individual McDonald's store prices. Any price information on TripAdvisor is user-submitted, covers only a small fraction of locations, and can be months or years out of date. MenuPriceTracker tracks store-level prices for 9,200+ US McDonald's locations across all 50 states, refreshed monthly from the McDonald's app.

Where does MenuPriceTracker get McDonald's price data?

Prices are collected at the store level from the McDonald's app, covering 9,200+ locations in every US state. Each store's data is refreshed monthly so you see real local prices — not a national estimate, a delivery markup, or crowdsourced guesses. The national average, state averages, and per-city averages on this site are all computed from that same store-level data.

McDonald's 3400 Sheridan Drive Prices

This McDonald's at 3400 Sheridan Drive, Amherst, NY 14226, Amherst charges $6.79 for a Big Mac as of October 2026, sourced directly from the McDonald's mobile app. The Amherst city average across 2 locations is $7.08. The US national average Big Mac price is $5.91.

Limited-time items currently showing at this specific store include Derpy McFlurry for $6.59 , Ramyeon McShaker Fries for $4.49 , Saja Boys Breakfast Meal for $7.69 . These promotional items are verified from the McDonald's app for this location and can vary by store or disappear when the offer ends.

Price Breakdown — Every Item at This Location

Derpy McFlurry

$6.59

State avg: $5.81

$0.78 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $6.59 for Derpy McFlurry. The state average is $5.81.

Ramyeon McShaker Fries

$4.49

State avg: $4.59

$0.10 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.49 for Ramyeon McShaker Fries. The state average is $4.59.

Saja Boys Breakfast Meal

$7.69

State avg: $9.08

$1.39 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $7.69 for Saja Boys Breakfast Meal. The state average is $9.08.

20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets

$8.59

State avg: $8.87

$0.28 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $8.59 for 20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets. The state average is $8.87.

Big Arch

$9.49

State avg: $9.26

$0.23 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $9.49 for Big Arch. The state average is $9.26.

Big Arch Large Meal

$13.79

State avg: $13.71

$0.08 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $13.79 for Big Arch Large Meal. The state average is $13.71.

Big Arch Meal

$12.99

State avg: $12.95

$0.04 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $12.99 for Big Arch Meal. The state average is $12.95.

Big Mac

$6.79

State avg: $6.9

$0.11 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $6.79 for Big Mac. The state average is $6.9.

Big Mac Large Meal

$10.59

State avg: $11.16

$0.57 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $10.59 for Big Mac Large Meal. The state average is $11.16.

Big Mac Meal

$9.89

State avg: $10.33

$0.44 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $9.89 for Big Mac Meal. The state average is $10.33.

Cheeseburger

$1.99

State avg: $2.65

$0.66 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.99 for Cheeseburger. The state average is $2.65.

Double Cheeseburger

$3.99

State avg: $3.85

$0.14 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.99 for Double Cheeseburger. The state average is $3.85.

Filet-O-Fish

$5.59

State avg: $5.9

$0.31 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.59 for Filet-O-Fish. The state average is $5.9.

McChicken

$2.79

State avg: $3.23

$0.44 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.79 for McChicken. The state average is $3.23.

Medium Coke

$1.39

State avg: $1.63

$0.24 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.39 for Medium Coke. The state average is $1.63.

Medium French Fries

$3.99

State avg: $4.07

$0.08 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.99 for Medium French Fries. The state average is $4.07.

Medium Latte

$3.89

State avg: $3.48

$0.41 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.89 for Medium Latte. The state average is $3.48.

Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice

$3.59

State avg: $3.37

$0.22 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.59 for Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice. The state average is $3.37.

Medium Premium Roast Coffee

$1.99

State avg: $2.08

$0.09 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.99 for Medium Premium Roast Coffee. The state average is $2.08.

Medium Strawberry Shake

$5.99

State avg: $4.94

$1.05 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.99 for Medium Strawberry Shake. The state average is $4.94.

Vanilla Cone

$2.59

State avg: $2.79

$0.20 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.59 for Vanilla Cone. The state average is $2.79.

Order Online: 🍔 McDonald's App → 📍 Store Page → Skip the line · Earn rewards

MenuPriceTracker.com is not affiliated with McDonald's Corporation. Prices are aggregated from store-level data and may not reflect current prices at this location.