McDonald's Menu Prices at 5136 Nesconset Hwy ★3.8 (920)

5136 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776

Photos & Reviews

📍 See all on Google Maps → Powered by Google
McDonald's store photo
McDonald's store photo
McDonald's store photo
Sal Sayed 3 weeks ago
★★★★☆

This McDonald’s location recently became a 24-hour operation, which is definitely a big plus. It is convenient to know you can stop by anytime, whether it is early morning or late at night. They have a very nice drive-thru setup and the service is usually pretty quick. Orders are handled efficiently, and I have not experienced long wait times. It runs the way you would expect a fast food place to run. Inside, everything is fairly standard. It is clean, organized, and straightforward. The staff does their job, the food comes out as expected, and overall it delivers a normal, reliable experience.

danielle ellis 7 months ago
★★★★☆

The presentation of the food was picture perfect! Our food was hott & fresh, my daily double was presented as a restaurant style burger. Our fires were golden fried & salted to perfection...The things I feel could be improved on are as follows: The drink & condiment station were removed which is a total inconvenience..To the fact that if you need more ketchup, napkins, or drink refills you have to go back to the counter & ask..Also it seems that no matter the time or location that you go to the ice cream machine is out of service..Ending on a positive note, the staff The staff was well informed about the menu items & mindful to our requests. They delivered our in a prompt & manner as well..We will definitely be back. great job.!!

Brooke Detweiler 2 months ago
★☆☆☆☆

This location repeatedly forgets items in orders. There really needs to be better quality control to ensure all items on the receipt are actually placed in the bag. Customers should not be charged for items they do not receive.

Paul Mallia 9 months ago
★★★★☆

Visit this McDonald's often as it is one of the closest to home. Most of the staff are very friendly and orders are always hot and fresh. Line always moves quickly and as someone who visits multiple times a week, sometimes if only for just a fountain drink, most orders are correct with no issues. Have been coming for years and will keep returning.

jeff vi 2 weeks ago
★★☆☆☆

Dining area has nothing but tables, they don't offer napkins, no soda refills, no TV, nothing, nothing, nothing. It's like waiting at a railroad station. It's the most uninviting McDonald's I've ever been too. All they care about is your money for overpriced food

ZIP 11776 Port Jefferson Station New York ⛅ 60°F · Partly Sunny · Oct 24

McDonald's Menu with Prices at This Location

How It Compares

This location
5136 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776
$7.59
Port Jefferson Station avg
Across 1 locations
$7.59
New York avg
Across 782 locations
$7.29
US National avg
All tracked US neighborhoods
$5.91

Nearby McDonald's Locations Within 5 Miles

After You Eat — What's Nearby?

🗺️

Port Jefferson Station offers a variety of attractions for everyone to enjoy, from cultural experiences at the Village Center to relaxing afternoons at Cedar Beach. Whether you're interested in the arts, outdoor activities, or enjoying a local brew, there's something for every visitor.

🌟 all
Port Jefferson Village Center
A cultural hub offering art exhibits, workshops, and community events.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Harborfront Park
A scenic waterfront park with walking trails, picnic areas, and a playground, perfect for relaxation and family outings.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Long Island Explorium
A hands-on science museum for children, offering interactive exhibits and educational programs.
🌟 all
Theatre Three
A local performing arts theater showcasing plays, musicals, and children's theater productions.
🧑 young adults
Port Jefferson Brewing Company
A craft brewery offering a variety of locally brewed beers and a cozy tasting room.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Rocketship Park (Clifton H. Lee Memorial Park)
A recently renovated park featuring modern playground equipment, basketball courts, and open spaces for recreation.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Cedar Beach
A nearby beach in Mount Sinai with sandy shores, picnic areas, and a fishing pier, ideal for a relaxing afternoon.
🌟 all
Port Jefferson Historical Society's Mather House Museum
A historic house museum offering insights into the area's maritime history and heritage.
🧑 young adults
The Velvet Lounge
A live music venue and bar featuring local bands, open mic nights, and a vibrant nightlife scene.
🌟 all
East Main & Main
A popular bakery and café known for its gourmet donuts and coffee, ideal for a sweet treat.
🌟 all
Port Jefferson Free Library
A community library offering book collections, public events, and educational programs for all ages.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Port Jefferson Farmers Market
A seasonal market offering fresh produce, baked goods, and artisanal products from local vendors.
🌟 all
Port Jefferson Cinemas
A local movie theater showing the latest films in a comfortable setting.
🧑 young adults
Port Jefferson Kayak
Offers kayak and paddleboard rentals for exploring the harbor and nearby waterways.
💑 couples
Danford's Hotel & Marina
A waterfront hotel offering spa services, dining, and beautiful views of the harbor, suitable for a romantic date night.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Port Jefferson Bowl
A family-friendly bowling alley offering leagues, open bowling, and arcade games.
🌟 all
The Steam Room
A casual seafood restaurant known for its lobster rolls and waterfront views, perfect for a relaxed meal.
🌟 all
The Frigate
A unique gift shop offering a variety of nautical-themed items, toys, and souvenirs.
🌟 all
John T. Mather Memorial Hospital Auxiliary Thrift Shop
A local thrift store offering a variety of second-hand goods, with proceeds supporting the hospital.
👨‍👩‍👧 families
Port Jefferson Ice Skating Rink
A seasonal outdoor ice skating rink located at Harborfront Park, offering fun for all ages during the winter months.

McDonald's 5136 Nesconset Hwy — Frequently Asked Questions

McDonald's menu prices at 5136 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station NY in 2026
The McDonald's menu at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY currently lists Big Mac at $7.59, Medium Fries at $4.19, and 20-piece Chicken McNuggets at $7.99. This store is also showing limited-time items including Derpy McFlurry at $5.89, Ramyeon McShaker Fries at $4.69, Saja Boys Breakfast Meal at $9.19. Every menu item on this page is pulled from the McDonald's app for this specific location and last verified October 2026.
How much is a Big Mac at McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy?
A Big Mac at the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY is $7.59 as of October 2026. The Port Jefferson Station city average is $7.59 and the US national average is $5.91. This location is $1.68 above the national average.
McDonald's fries price at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station
Medium French Fries at the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY are $4.19 as of October 2026. See how this compares to other Port Jefferson Station stores on our city page.
McNuggets price on the McDonald's menu at 5136 Nesconset Hwy
20-piece Chicken McNuggets at the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY cost $7.99 as of October 2026. Compare McNuggets prices at other Port Jefferson Station stores on our city page.
Is the limited-time Derpy McFlurry available at McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy?
Yes. The limited-time Derpy McFlurry is currently listed at the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY for $5.89 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.
Is the limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries available at McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy?
Yes. The limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries is currently listed at the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY for $4.69 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.
Is the limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal available at McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy?
Yes. The limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal is currently listed at the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY for $9.19 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.
Is the McDonald's menu at 5136 Nesconset Hwy more expensive than the Port Jefferson Station average?
The Big Mac at this McDonald's is $7.59. The Port Jefferson Station, NY average Big Mac is $7.59, and the US national average is $5.91. Compare individual items above to see how this store ranks.
Why are McDonald's menu prices at 5136 Nesconset Hwy different from other locations?
McDonald's menu prices at 5136 Nesconset Hwy are set by the local franchise owner — not McDonald's corporate. Port Jefferson Station averages $7.59 for a Big Mac, which is $1.68 above the US average of $5.91. There are 1 McDonald's in Port Jefferson Station — visit our city page to compare them all.
How many items are on the McDonald's menu at 5136 Nesconset Hwy?
This McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY has 21 menu items listed above with current app prices. Browse the full menu on this page or compare with other locations in Port Jefferson Station.
When were McDonald's menu prices at 5136 Nesconset Hwy last updated?
Prices for the McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY were last verified October 2026. We source data from the McDonald's mobile app. Franchise owners can adjust prices at any time — check back for the latest.
What is there to do near McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station?
Port Jefferson Station offers a variety of attractions for everyone to enjoy, from cultural experiences at the Village Center to relaxing afternoons at Cedar Beach. Whether you're interested in the arts, outdoor activities, or enjoying a local brew, there's something for every visitor. Top nearby spots: Port Jefferson Village Center — A cultural hub offering art exhibits, workshops, and community events.; Harborfront Park — A scenic waterfront park with walking trails, picnic areas, and a playground, perfect for relaxation and family outings.; Long Island Explorium — A hands-on science museum for children, offering interactive exhibits and educational programs.; Theatre Three — A local performing arts theater showcasing plays, musicals, and children's theater productions.; Port Jefferson Brewing Company — A craft brewery offering a variety of locally brewed beers and a cozy tasting room..
What McDonald's locations are near 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station?
There are 4 McDonald's locations within 5 miles of 5136 Nesconset Hwy in Port Jefferson Station, NY: 1. McDonald's at 340 Rt 25a, Miller Place, NY 11764 (3.5 mi away) — rated 3.7 out of 5; 2. McDonald's at 1724 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720 (4.5 mi away) — rated 3.8 out of 5; 3. McDonald's at 313 Middle Country Rd, Coram, NY 11727 (4.5 mi away) — rated 3.7 out of 5.

MenuPriceTracker vs. Delivery Apps & Other Price Sites

How do these prices compare to what Uber Eats, DoorDash, or Grubhub show?

Uber Eats, DoorDash, Grubhub, and Seamless inflate McDonald's menu prices by 15–30% on top of the in-store price before adding delivery fees, service fees, and tip. The price you see on a delivery app is not what McDonald's charges at the counter. MenuPriceTracker shows the real menu price from the McDonald's app — what you'd actually pay walking into the restaurant or ordering at the kiosk.

Why not just check TripAdvisor for McDonald's prices?

TripAdvisor doesn't track individual McDonald's store prices. Any price information on TripAdvisor is user-submitted, covers only a small fraction of locations, and can be months or years out of date. MenuPriceTracker tracks store-level prices for 9,200+ US McDonald's locations across all 50 states, refreshed monthly from the McDonald's app.

Where does MenuPriceTracker get McDonald's price data?

Prices are collected at the store level from the McDonald's app, covering 9,200+ locations in every US state. Each store's data is refreshed monthly so you see real local prices — not a national estimate, a delivery markup, or crowdsourced guesses. The national average, state averages, and per-city averages on this site are all computed from that same store-level data.

McDonald's 5136 Nesconset Hwy Prices

This McDonald's at 5136 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, Port Jefferson Station charges $7.59 for a Big Mac as of October 2026, sourced directly from the McDonald's mobile app. The Port Jefferson Station city average across 1 location is $7.59. The US national average Big Mac price is $5.91.

Limited-time items currently showing at this specific store include Derpy McFlurry for $5.89 , Ramyeon McShaker Fries for $4.69 , Saja Boys Breakfast Meal for $9.19 . These promotional items are verified from the McDonald's app for this location and can vary by store or disappear when the offer ends.

Price Breakdown — Every Item at This Location

Derpy McFlurry
$5.89
State avg: $5.81
$0.08 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.89 for Derpy McFlurry. The state average is $5.81.

Ramyeon McShaker Fries
$4.69
State avg: $4.59
$0.10 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.69 for Ramyeon McShaker Fries. The state average is $4.59.

Saja Boys Breakfast Meal
$9.19
State avg: $9.08
$0.11 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $9.19 for Saja Boys Breakfast Meal. The state average is $9.08.

20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets
$7.99
State avg: $8.87
$0.88 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $7.99 for 20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets. The state average is $8.87.

Big Arch
$9.39
State avg: $9.26
$0.13 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $9.39 for Big Arch. The state average is $9.26.

Big Arch Large Meal
$13.79
State avg: $13.71
$0.08 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $13.79 for Big Arch Large Meal. The state average is $13.71.

Big Arch Meal
$12.99
State avg: $12.95
$0.04 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $12.99 for Big Arch Meal. The state average is $12.95.

Big Mac
$7.59
State avg: $6.9
$0.69 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $7.59 for Big Mac. The state average is $6.9.

Big Mac Large Meal
$11.69
State avg: $11.16
$0.53 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $11.69 for Big Mac Large Meal. The state average is $11.16.

Big Mac Meal
$10.89
State avg: $10.33
$0.56 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $10.89 for Big Mac Meal. The state average is $10.33.

Cheeseburger
$2.99
State avg: $2.65
$0.34 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.99 for Cheeseburger. The state average is $2.65.

Double Cheeseburger
$3.89
State avg: $3.85
$0.04 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.89 for Double Cheeseburger. The state average is $3.85.

Filet-O-Fish
$5.89
State avg: $5.9
$0.01 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.89 for Filet-O-Fish. The state average is $5.9.

McChicken
$3.79
State avg: $3.23
$0.56 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.79 for McChicken. The state average is $3.23.

Medium Coke
$1.69
State avg: $1.63
$0.06 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.69 for Medium Coke. The state average is $1.63.

Medium French Fries
$4.19
State avg: $4.07
$0.12 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.19 for Medium French Fries. The state average is $4.07.

Medium Latte
$3.19
State avg: $3.48
$0.29 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.19 for Medium Latte. The state average is $3.48.

Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice
$3.69
State avg: $3.37
$0.32 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.69 for Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice. The state average is $3.37.

Medium Premium Roast Coffee
$2.69
State avg: $2.08
$0.61 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.69 for Medium Premium Roast Coffee. The state average is $2.08.

Medium Strawberry Shake
$5.49
State avg: $4.94
$0.55 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.49 for Medium Strawberry Shake. The state average is $4.94.

Vanilla Cone
$3.49
State avg: $2.79
$0.70 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.49 for Vanilla Cone. The state average is $2.79.

Order Online: 🍔 McDonald's App → 📍 Store Page → Skip the line · Earn rewards

MenuPriceTracker.com is not affiliated with McDonald's Corporation. Prices are aggregated from store-level data and may not reflect current prices at this location.