McDonald's Menu Prices at 971 Montauk Hwy ★3.7 (1649)

971 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11786

Dari “darikyun” V a month ago

★★★★★

This is my favorite local McDonald's, it salways clean and the service is great with very little errors, if any. This one had play place!!

Darren Gopaul 6 months ago

★☆☆☆☆

I visited this McDonald’s location around 5:00 AM and was very disappointed with the service. After waiting at the drive-thru speaker with no response, I pulled up to the window where staff were present but made no effort to acknowledge or assist me for roughly 3 mins. The man finally came to address it, while the woman who was in charge of the drive thru ignored me. For a restaurant that advertises 24/7 service, this experience was unprofessional and frustrating. Consistency and attentiveness—especially during overnight hours—are important, and I hope management addresses this issue.

Bianca Buonomo 4 months ago

★★☆☆☆

Received 3 items that should have had monopoly pieces with nothing. Also received a boo bucket with no bangle. My daughter is SO disappointed.

N Fran (nfran) a month ago

★☆☆☆☆

I just left this location and I don’t really do reviews much. EVERY drink was “sold out” and the fries were RAW and cold. The sandwich was DISGUSTING. This place should be out of business. 19.97 in the garbage. Bread hard as a rock, burnt (was it moldy and needed to be burnt) WHAT A COMPLETE WASTE and I’m 20 mins away or I’d would have asked for my money back. SHAME ON McDonald’s, THE ONWER of this location, MANAGER, and the EMPLOYEES.

A a year ago

★★★★★

Maica was great 👍,.. great place , staff members were very friendly, polite and professional make me feel welcome. Also place was very clean and organized. Will come bac

ZIP 11786 Shirley New York ☁️ 43°F · Cloudy · Oct 22

McDonald's Menu with Prices at This Location

How It Compares

Nearby McDonald's Locations Within 5 Miles

After You Eat — What's Nearby?

🗺️

🌟 all

Smith Point County Park

Located on Fire Island, this park offers a beautiful beachfront along the Atlantic Ocean, ideal for swimming, surfing, and beachcombing.

👨‍👩‍👧 families

Heckscher State Park

This 1,657-acre park features picnic areas, playgrounds, hiking and biking trails, and a disc golf course, perfect for a family outing.

👨‍👩‍👧 families

Adventureland Amusement Park

An amusement park offering a variety of rides and attractions suitable for all ages, providing a fun-filled day for families and thrill-seekers.

👨‍👩‍👧 families

Xplore Family Fun Center

This indoor adventure center features Long Island’s largest laser tag arena, a ninja course, inflatables, and a multi-sport turf field, making it ideal for family entertainment.

🌟 all

Smith Haven Mall

This shopping center boasts over 100 stores, including major retailers and dining options, making it a great spot for shopping and entertainment.

🌟 couples|all

Heckscher Park

This park includes the Heckscher Museum of Art and hosts various cultural events, concerts, and festivals throughout the year.

🌟 families|all

Christopher Morley Park

Offering playgrounds, walking paths, and swimming pools, this park provides a variety of recreational activities for all ages.

🌟 all

Mastics-Moriches-Shirley Community Library

This local library hosts various events and workshops, catering to a wide range of interests and educational programs.

🌟 all

Retro & Classic Car Show

An event showcasing classic and retro cars, presented by The Chamber of Commerce of the Mastics & Shirley, happening at the LIDL Store Parking Lot.

💑 couples

Gurney’s Montauk

This venue hosts various events and offers luxurious amenities, including a spa and fine dining, ideal for a date night.

McDonald's 971 Montauk Hwy — Frequently Asked Questions

McDonald's menu prices at 971 Montauk Hwy, Shirley NY in 2026

The McDonald's menu at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY currently lists Big Mac at $7.29, Medium Fries at $3.99, and 20-piece Chicken McNuggets at $7.99. This store is also showing limited-time items including Derpy McFlurry at $5.69, Ramyeon McShaker Fries at $4.49, Saja Boys Breakfast Meal at $8.89. Every menu item on this page is pulled from the McDonald's app for this specific location and last verified October 2026.

How much is a Big Mac at McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy?

A Big Mac at the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY is $7.29 as of October 2026. The Shirley city average is $7.29 and the US national average is $5.91. This location is $1.38 above the national average.

McDonald's fries price at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley

Medium French Fries at the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY are $3.99 as of October 2026. See how this compares to other Shirley stores on our city page.

McNuggets price on the McDonald's menu at 971 Montauk Hwy

20-piece Chicken McNuggets at the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY cost $7.99 as of October 2026. Compare McNuggets prices at other Shirley stores on our city page.

Is the limited-time Derpy McFlurry available at McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy?

Yes. The limited-time Derpy McFlurry is currently listed at the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY for $5.69 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.

Is the limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries available at McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy?

Yes. The limited-time Ramyeon McShaker Fries is currently listed at the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY for $4.49 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.

Is the limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal available at McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy?

Yes. The limited-time Saja Boys Breakfast Meal is currently listed at the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY for $8.89 as of October 2026. This availability is verified from the McDonald's app for this specific store, and limited-time items can differ by location or disappear when the promotion ends.

Is the McDonald's menu at 971 Montauk Hwy more expensive than the Shirley average?

The Big Mac at this McDonald's is $7.29. The Shirley, NY average Big Mac is $7.29, and the US national average is $5.91. Compare individual items above to see how this store ranks.

Why are McDonald's menu prices at 971 Montauk Hwy different from other locations?

McDonald's menu prices at 971 Montauk Hwy are set by the local franchise owner — not McDonald's corporate. Shirley averages $7.29 for a Big Mac, which is $1.38 above the US average of $5.91. There are 1 McDonald's in Shirley — visit our city page to compare them all.

How many items are on the McDonald's menu at 971 Montauk Hwy?

This McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY has 21 menu items listed above with current app prices. Browse the full menu on this page or compare with other locations in Shirley.

When were McDonald's menu prices at 971 Montauk Hwy last updated?

Prices for the McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY were last verified October 2026. We source data from the McDonald's mobile app. Franchise owners can adjust prices at any time — check back for the latest.

What is there to do near McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley?

For a fun day out, consider visiting Smith Point County Park for its beautiful beach, or Heckscher State Park for a picnic and some outdoor activities. Families can enjoy Adventureland Amusement Park or the Xplore Family Fun Center for some exciting entertainment options. Top nearby spots: Smith Point County Park — Located on Fire Island, this park offers a beautiful beachfront along the Atlantic Ocean, ideal for swimming, surfing, and beachcombing.; Heckscher State Park — This 1,657-acre park features picnic areas, playgrounds, hiking and biking trails, and a disc golf course, perfect for a family outing.; Adventureland Amusement Park — An amusement park offering a variety of rides and attractions suitable for all ages, providing a fun-filled day for families and thrill-seekers.; Xplore Family Fun Center — This indoor adventure center features Long Island’s largest laser tag arena, a ninja course, inflatables, and a multi-sport turf field, making it ideal for family entertainment.; Smith Haven Mall — This shopping center boasts over 100 stores, including major retailers and dining options, making it a great spot for shopping and entertainment..

What McDonald's locations are near 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley?

There is 1 McDonald's location within 5 miles of 971 Montauk Hwy in Shirley, NY: 1. McDonald's at 626 Montauk Hwy, Center Moriches, NY 11934 (3.1 mi away) — rated 3.8 out of 5.

MenuPriceTracker vs. Delivery Apps & Other Price Sites

How do these prices compare to what Uber Eats, DoorDash, or Grubhub show?

Uber Eats, DoorDash, Grubhub, and Seamless inflate McDonald's menu prices by 15–30% on top of the in-store price before adding delivery fees, service fees, and tip. The price you see on a delivery app is not what McDonald's charges at the counter. MenuPriceTracker shows the real menu price from the McDonald's app — what you'd actually pay walking into the restaurant or ordering at the kiosk.

Why not just check TripAdvisor for McDonald's prices?

TripAdvisor doesn't track individual McDonald's store prices. Any price information on TripAdvisor is user-submitted, covers only a small fraction of locations, and can be months or years out of date. MenuPriceTracker tracks store-level prices for 9,200+ US McDonald's locations across all 50 states, refreshed monthly from the McDonald's app.

Where does MenuPriceTracker get McDonald's price data?

Prices are collected at the store level from the McDonald's app, covering 9,200+ locations in every US state. Each store's data is refreshed monthly so you see real local prices — not a national estimate, a delivery markup, or crowdsourced guesses. The national average, state averages, and per-city averages on this site are all computed from that same store-level data.

McDonald's 971 Montauk Hwy Prices

This McDonald's at 971 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11786, Shirley charges $7.29 for a Big Mac as of October 2026, sourced directly from the McDonald's mobile app. The Shirley city average across 1 location is $7.29. The US national average Big Mac price is $5.91.

Limited-time items currently showing at this specific store include Derpy McFlurry for $5.69 , Ramyeon McShaker Fries for $4.49 , Saja Boys Breakfast Meal for $8.89 . These promotional items are verified from the McDonald's app for this location and can vary by store or disappear when the offer ends.

Price Breakdown — Every Item at This Location

Derpy McFlurry

$5.69

State avg: $5.81

$0.12 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.69 for Derpy McFlurry. The state average is $5.81.

Ramyeon McShaker Fries

$4.49

State avg: $4.59

$0.10 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $4.49 for Ramyeon McShaker Fries. The state average is $4.59.

Saja Boys Breakfast Meal

$8.89

State avg: $9.08

$0.19 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $8.89 for Saja Boys Breakfast Meal. The state average is $9.08.

20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets

$7.99

State avg: $8.87

$0.88 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $7.99 for 20 Pc. Chicken McNuggets. The state average is $8.87.

Big Arch

$8.99

State avg: $9.26

$0.27 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $8.99 for Big Arch. The state average is $9.26.

Big Arch Large Meal

$14.98

State avg: $13.71

$1.27 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $14.98 for Big Arch Large Meal. The state average is $13.71.

Big Arch Meal

$14.28

State avg: $12.95

$1.33 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $14.28 for Big Arch Meal. The state average is $12.95.

Big Mac

$7.29

State avg: $6.9

$0.39 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $7.29 for Big Mac. The state average is $6.9.

Big Mac Large Meal

$11.49

State avg: $11.16

$0.33 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $11.49 for Big Mac Large Meal. The state average is $11.16.

Big Mac Meal

$10.29

State avg: $10.33

$0.04 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $10.29 for Big Mac Meal. The state average is $10.33.

Cheeseburger

$2.99

State avg: $2.65

$0.34 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.99 for Cheeseburger. The state average is $2.65.

Double Cheeseburger

$3.99

State avg: $3.85

$0.14 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.99 for Double Cheeseburger. The state average is $3.85.

Filet-O-Fish

$5.19

State avg: $5.9

$0.71 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.19 for Filet-O-Fish. The state average is $5.9.

McChicken

$3.39

State avg: $3.23

$0.16 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.39 for McChicken. The state average is $3.23.

Medium Coke

$1.89

State avg: $1.63

$0.26 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $1.89 for Medium Coke. The state average is $1.63.

Medium French Fries

$3.99

State avg: $4.07

$0.08 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.99 for Medium French Fries. The state average is $4.07.

Medium Latte

$3.99

State avg: $3.48

$0.51 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.99 for Medium Latte. The state average is $3.48.

Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice

$3.69

State avg: $3.37

$0.32 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $3.69 for Medium Minute Maid Orange Juice. The state average is $3.37.

Medium Premium Roast Coffee

$2.59

State avg: $2.08

$0.51 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.59 for Medium Premium Roast Coffee. The state average is $2.08.

Medium Strawberry Shake

$5.19

State avg: $4.94

$0.25 above state avg

This McDonald's charges $5.19 for Medium Strawberry Shake. The state average is $4.94.

Vanilla Cone

$2.49

State avg: $2.79

$0.30 below state avg

This McDonald's charges $2.49 for Vanilla Cone. The state average is $2.79.

Order Online: 🍔 McDonald's App → 📍 Store Page → Skip the line · Earn rewards

MenuPriceTracker.com is not affiliated with McDonald's Corporation. Prices are aggregated from store-level data and may not reflect current prices at this location.